You're supposed to drop acid and THEN watch Toy Story. JE, you were doing it wrong.
TS3 was the best. The one thing my wife and I will always agree on are animated movies. She's obsessed with Robotech. It's pretty bad, but I still feel lucky.
I've been married a long time now, so I know the drill.
If she wants to watch reality crap (or romcom) I use it as an excuse to grab a beer and a smoke and watch what I want in another room. She ends up feeling bad after an hour and I get sexy time.
If she wants to rent a sappy movie from redbox, I always get one for myself. She falls asleep at the end of said sappy movie and I put my good movie in. She sleeps and I enjoy.