I disagree. Tenure shouldn’t matter one bit, otherwise Frank Gore should be our starter at RB next year.
If we draft Sewell (or any other OT prospect) it’s a competition, best player wins loser shifts to the right side. I expect Becton to win, but I’m going to make him prove it in that scenario. If he does excellent, it plays out as I thought. If he loses then the better player is protecting the blindside.
How on Earth is that a bad thing?
As for paying guys, that’s a 4 years from now problem, and one we haven’t had in nearly a decade. There’s also no guarantee both continue to play at an elite level. There’s also the chance of you draft Liam Eichenberg (or whomever) at 27 with the Seattle Pick and they become the best OT in the class and you have to worry about paying that guy too.
Draft the best players period.
I agree. Becton was very good for a rookie this year, but I don't think he was so good where he can't be moved to LT just because he's one year older. If Sewell is a better fit at LT and Becton works equally well on both sides, do what's best for the team. Of course, if Becton thinks it's a demotion to be moved to the right side and clearly doesn't want to do it, then we don't really want to pee him off.
I don't care if we have to pay 2 elite OT. One elite OL doesn't make an offensive line. I think you want at least 2 studs up front ideally, and we would have that. We can go cheaper on the interior line once they get paid. It's not like paying 2 elite safeties.
But if Fields and/or Wilson are viewed as elite QB prospects by the NFL, we should either take them, or use the #2 pick to trade down to someone who will take them. We have a ton of needs to fill, and if we maintain that flexibility, we could also use those draft picks to make a big trade for someone down the line.
It's possible the media is higher on Fields/Wilson than NFL teams, and my scenario isn't realistic. But if those guys are franchise QBs, we should either take them or trade down and get the value of a franchise QB. Taking a right tackle at 2 is not the best use of that asset.
I felt the same way 2 years ago with Quinnen. The difference is that year, a trade down wasn't really realistic since there weren't QBs to trade up for. This year, there are.