1- Agreed. Completely fair and factual criticism.
2- See #1.
3- The posting of the fines in the team facility is a bad look, Enunwa is also 100% wrong.
4- Overblown by Manish who's clearly operating with an agenda likely because he's not getting the access he previously enjoyed. Meh. I've heard him blame himself plenty after losses.
5- The best thing he's done here IMHO aside from having Sam play on a clear upward trajectory since the Jaguars game. Mac sucked.
6- I don't think he's ever said that.
7- Fair considering the second half performances for the most part, and I think especially reared its head after the Darnold INT last Sunday.
8- Yeah, Andy Reid does it most of the time he's not talking to his quarterback.
9- C'mon, really.
10- I don't recall so I can't comment on it except to say freak Brian Winters.
So let's start with the fact that you agree there is some very valid criticism. Specifically in-game and gameplanning issues. Those are the core of his job, no? If he's bad at them, that's reason for him to be unemployed alone, no?
I'm not quoting anything from Manish. Other than some of his tweets, I haven't read a thing from Manish this year. I watch the postgame show with more interest than the games at this point. The things I say Gase says or does in them, I've witnessed with my own 2 eyes.
Was it good to get rid of Maccagnan? Ends-justify-the-means says yes. And I wanted him gone before anyone except SFD. But it's the snake-style garbage that I don't like. That's not a one-time thing from someone. That's who they are. Maccagnan signed off on Gase's hiring only to be stabbed in the back.
You don't think he's ever said he didn't want to give Bell and Mosley the money they got? I mean, Ian Rappaport isn't Manish:
http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000001030898/article/adam-gase-disagreed-with-price-tag-for-bell-mosley My problem with things like sitting on the bench alone or having someone else in charge of the challenge flag are: the head coach should be directly involved in all 3 phases of the game. His job is to oversee the 3 units, not play with his own toys in the corner.
And agreed, freak Brian Winters. But again, a head coach needs to take care of garbage like that. Not put the guy right back in the game. And even if he didn't know what happened then, how did Winters get to start the next week as well?