So you think Adam Gase won the Miami game? Not Sam Darnold somehow connecting with Vyncint Smith? Nor thanks to a gift by replay officials that got them an overturn on an uncalled DPI? Nor because Greg Williams prepared a mediocre defense to hold a great red zone offense to nothing but field goals?
It really comes down to whether you believe his teams win because of him or in spite of him. Needless to say, I fall into the latter category.
I'm not going to classify that as a gift considering the calls that went against the Jets, specifically the ridiculous roughing the passer call on Shep and the holding call on the interception. Not to mention the fact that the play in question actually was actually pass interference.
By virtue of being the head coach, it goes as a win on his record, does it not? If you can acknowledge that the talent on this team is wanting, or "terrible" as you call it (and I agree, certain position groups you can argue are the worst in the league), then surely a guy who can put up a .500 record with said terrible talent can't be that bad a head coach.