I'm having 2013 flashbacks.
The most disappointing draft pick of my recent life is Christian Hackenberg. I do not even know what is 2nd at this point.
Every 1st-round pick you could make a real case for being a good pick, even if a lot of them didn't work out. Even guys like Pryor and Coples and Lee which seemed like odd picks at the time. I know everyone here hated Geno, but I was fine with him in round 2. Round 1 would have been a disaster.
Christian Hackenberg should not have been drafted. Anyone who watched him play in college saw how bad he was. And we took him in the 2nd round. That was the most predictably bad pick we've ever had. Mike Nugent honorable mention.