I don't typically study tape until the off-season, and just some quick observations.
I would love it if Blake Bortles or Bryce Petty (Have watched quite a bit of Baylor this year) come out this year. Bryce Petty plays for a run first offense by design, but winds up being very pass happy (They take a lot of snaps per game). Baylor is a run first team though. He also doesn't tend to see much pressure, and as a one year starter, that scares me. How do can you judge his pocket presence under pressure? He reminds me of a more gifted passer than Jake Locker, or a Tim Tebow that can pass 6'3" 230lbs and faster. He fits what Rex Ryan is trying to build, IMO. I haven't really studied Bortles, but from what I have seen from him, I would take him in a heart beat.
AJ McCarron reminds me of Alex Smith, and he would be a perfect fit for our offense. Take care of the football, but he can make the necessary throws. The ultimate game manager, IMO. However, a talented team like Alabama concerns me. It isn't fair to judge him based on his teammates, but they don't play teams that have like talent. In the pros he will have to, so it is a valid concern.
Zach Mettenberger has raised some questions to his decision making the past couple weeks. However, he is having to put the team on his shoulders lately, and not rely on a great defense that he had the luxury of last year. He has had a pretty dominate runner behind him in though.
The one player I do not want is Manziel. I don't see the maturity of a franchise QB, and though he is exciting to watch at the college level, it doesn't mean it will translate.
Bridgewater will be long gone.
That all said, Simms has really impressed me. I don't know why he didn't play much in college, but I doubt it was from a physical aspect. I am guessing it was more of a lack of maturity, and was someone that didn't have to work for anything. His release is as good as anyone I have ever seen, and I like how he moves in the pocket. However, he has made some pretty bad decisions in the limited game time he has seen, so there's that.