I'm pretty sure I remember a whole lot of "I didn't want Geno, but it's a second round pick so it's fine." I don't remember anyone freaking out that it was a steal or that it would be the worst pick we ever made.
I hated it, and was vocal about it during training camp.
Once he was named the starter, I remember saying its a cheap option.
And then Mike Vick became his backup, and my fandom took a direct hit. freak this franchise.