Divisional Round 2013

[Ignatius J Reilly]

I could get behind that matchup assuming the Panthers win.

I'd be good with either.  Another Manning SB win further diminishes the claim that Brady is the greatest QB of all time.

[Johnny English]

I could get behind that matchup assuming the Panthers win.

We really want Denver to win, and then repeat next year. It removes one more NE argument about Brady being the best QB of his generation.

[Badger]

Peyton's unreal regular season is good enough for that.

I won't be upset if the Broncos win, and it definitely wouldn't be surprising, but after the Patriots they're the team I'd least like to see win it all.

[Heismanberg]

Peyton's unreal regular season is good enough for that.

The rings argument will always be there for NE fans though. 

[Badger]

Doesn't bother me enough to root for Peyton after a decade of resentment.

[Italian Seafood]

The rings argument will always be there for NE fans though. 

If Peyton gets one here he would be 2-1 in the Super Bowl, to Brady's 3-2. Brady would still have a slight edge but not nearly as much, and Peyton would have done it with two separate teams/coaches.

Man, if that happens and nyjunc ever posts here regularly it could get ugly.

[Heismanberg]

I've said this a lot over the past decade:

Tom Brady is the best quarterback of this era

Peyton Manning is the best passer of this era

[Badger]

I've said this a lot over the past decade:

Tom Brady is the best quarterback of this era

Peyton Manning is the best passer of this era

I love making the passer/quarterback distinction when comparing two players, but once in a while someone responds to it with "what r u talkin about, its the same thing dumb derriere."

[Johnny English]

I've said this a lot over the past decade:

Tom Brady is the best quarterback of this era

Peyton Manning is the best passer of this era

I think that's a little unfair on Peyton and I don't agree with it really, but I don't want to go all nyjunc.

[Miamipuck]

I've said this a lot over the past decade:

Tom Brady is the best quarterback of this era

Peyton Manning is the best passer of this era

What r u talking about, it's the same damn thing dumbass.

[Heismanberg]

I think that's a little unfair on Peyton and I don't agree with it really, but I don't want to go all nyjunc.

Who would you take in the playoffs or in a two-minute drill to win the game?

Tom Brady gets it done more than Peyton Manning. 

[Badger]

Who would you take in the playoffs or in a two-minute drill to win the game?

The Sanchize or Geno "late hit magnet" Smith

[Miamipuck]

Who would you take in the playoffs or in a two-minute drill to win the game?

Tom Brady gets it done more than Peyton Manning. 

Eli gets that done more often.

[Italian Seafood]

I would take Brady every time.

More than that, I would love for nyjunc to post here more often. We could finally start the UNC vs The World forum we discussed on TGG. Speaking of which, I recently went to post something there and discovered I'm no longer "authorized" to post there, but my account is still logged in and that works. Weird.

[Johnny English]

Who would you take in the playoffs or in a two-minute drill to win the game?

Tom Brady gets it done more than Peyton Manning. 

If I want someone to win the game for me inside the first 58 minutes I'm taking Peyton though.

Brady can be beaten by defenses. We see it happen every season - defeat the NE game plan and you can win going away. Yes, it's difficult, and yes, chasing a close game down inside the last two minutes Brady is out of this world, but I still don't think that he or anyone else is on Peyton's level when it comes to reading and reacting to a defensive scheme.